This chapter had some really great tips on how to help
students read through a textbook, and possible strategies to have them do less
or no reading in the textbook. I was disappointed
that so many of the strategies wouldn’t work well in the math classroom. For example, they talked about book clubs and
Jigsaw reading, which I really don’t see as effective strategies with a math
textbook. There is potential with the
vocabulary word sorting strategy and I really did connect to the material
asking us to get the students out of the textbook. I recently posted a TED Talk where he took a
problem from a textbook and created a real video of it happening! That is so
much more effective than just assigning seven pages a night so they can get
through it all. I think students can
learn a lot better in a classroom where a teacher is dedicated to teaching
outside of the textbook, in words the students can understand. Yes, they should
learn the math vocabulary, but that does not mean that it isn’t useful for them
to hear something in normal words first and begin to understand how math
vocabulary connects to it after. I could
see myself putting vocabulary words and textbook definitions up on the board,
and having students help me break down the definition until everyone can
understand it. This strategy could help
them throughout the unit as well as later in life when they come across words
and definitions that they don’t understand.
(254)
(254)
Hi Callie! I too want to teach math so reading this chapter was interesting to me because math textbooks are so different from any other textbook. There is so much information in each line of the text making skimming impossible. In other textbooks where you can skip some of the concepts and still get the general idea, this is not the same for math. I thought part of the text was interesting when it talked about working through the text concept by concept and doing some sort of Jigsaw fitted specifically for concepts. Obviously this wouldn’t work for all parts of the text because a lot of math concepts build off each other but it is an idea that I could see being useful if done properly!
ReplyDelete127 Words
Callie, your critique is spot on. We should talk about this.
ReplyDelete